Welcome to Scary Movie Club of America! Here are the collected mini-reviews of all horror movies that I've watched. I've rated them out of 100, built up of 10 categories at 10 points each. Here are the criteria I used to rate each movie:

Acting - The higher the number, the better the acting. 
Anxiety - Did I feel tense while watching this movie? I hope so. 
Atmosphere - Big one here. Setting + Mood + Soundtrack, all rolled into one.
% Movie Watched - I’m big enough to admit that I won’t watch a whole movie if it stinks.
Appropriate Grossness - Does the movie deserve the gore and violence? Or were those elements forced?
Production - How does the movie look? Is the CGI horrible? Are the sets goofy? Hope not. 
Recommended - Should you watch this movie? 
Unpredictable - I generally don’t love movies for which I guess the ending within the first half.
Scares - Here are your classic jumps, frights, and boogedie-boogedies. I like these, generally.
Story - Am I watching a story that’s been told a hundred times? I hope not.

This list is mostly reference for myself so I can remember the movies I've watched and haven't watched. It gets hard to remember, ya know? Particularly with the stinkers, or the ones so bad I only watched for 30 minutes. Enjoy the list - it's alphabetical, and my score out of 100 is above each title.